Network Working Group                                        R.T. BradenRequest for Comments: 338                                       UCLA/CCNNIC: 9931                                                    17 May 1972                  EBCDIC/ASCII MAPPING FOR NETWORK RJEA. INTRODUCTION   Under NETRJS [1], CCN's Network rje protocol [2], a virtual remote   batch terminal may be either EBCDIC or ASCII.  CCN operates an IBM   360/91 which performs all of its normal processing in EBCDIC.  When a   virtual ASCII terminal signs onto NETRJS, CCN translates the "card   reader" stream to EBCDIC and translates the "printer" stream back to   ASCII [3].   In recent months, a number of ASCII hosts (RAND PDP-10, Utah PDP-10,   Illinois PDP-11) have completed user processes for NETRJS.  Several   users at these sites have noted deficiencies in the ASCII/EBCDIC   mapping rules originally implemented in NETRJS.  Since their   objections were well founded, we have altered the existing mapping   and added a new one.   This RFC has three purposes:      (1) to make all users of NETRJS aware of the changed ASCII mapping      (2) to call this problem to the attention of the Network RJE          Protocol Committee      (3) to knowledge and support Joel Winett's pioneering work [4] in          this area.THE EBCDIC CHIMERA   A year ago, Joel Winett Published RFC #183, containing the results of   his careful research into just what EBCDIC really means.  He sounded   a clarion call for all EBCDIC sites to join in defining a Network   standards mapping.  At this time, we at CCN were primarily absorbed   in the timely implementation of the NETRJS protocol to serve an   EBCDIC (!) user site, RAND, so we were not very supportive of his   efforts.   RFC #183 is a valuable document; we hope a copy falls into the hands   of Armonk.  It is clear from RFC #183 that EBCDIC consists of a   standard ("basic") set of characters, combined with a number of   overlapping ad-hoc character happenings.  Fortunately, if we excludeBraden                                                          [Page 1]RFC 338           EBCDIC/ASCII MAPPING FOR NETWORK RJE          May 1972   special-purpose text composition programs, IBM 360 programs use only   the 89 "basic" EBCDIC graphics [5] shown in RFC #183 as well as in   Figure 1.  An IBM 029 "EBCDIC" keypunch can create 63 graphics: the   89 basic EBCDIC graphics less the 26 lower case letters.  In fact,   OS/360 requires an even smaller subset of EBCDIC, 60 characters   commonly called the "PL/1 character set".  The PL/1 set consists of   the 89 basic graphics, less the 26 lower case letters as well as the   three graphics <cent sign>!" (cent sign, exclamation point, and   quotation).C. CHARACTER MAPPING IN NETRJS   We consider now the requirements of a ASCII/EBCDIC mapping for NETRJS   or any rje protocol.  These requirements are as follows:      Efficiency:      The translation should be character-to-character, so that the CPU      operation "translate" can be used and character scans obviated.      This is important because a significant volume of character data      may be moved during rje operations.      Usability:      (1) All of the 89 EBCDIC graphics should be mapped into          corresponding ASCII characters.      (2) The mapping should be as nearly transparent as possible, i.e.,          whenever the same graphic appears in both sets, it should map          onto itself.      (3) To minimize the adaptation required of an EBCDIC-oriented          programmer, the ASCII graphics should evoke the corresponding          EBCDIC graphic, when they are not identical.   Theses considerations led us to incorporate Winett's rules II (a) and   III (b) (see page 4 of the RFC #183) into NETRJS:        ASCII                EBCDIC        -----                ------          |                     |          ~                 <bent bar>          \                 <cent sign>Braden                                                          [Page 2]RFC 338           EBCDIC/ASCII MAPPING FOR NETWORK RJE          May 1972   This defines all 89 basic EBCDIC graphics in terms of ASCII.   However, there is still a question of how to map the 6 "maverick"   ASCII characters ( []{}^` ) which are not in EBCDIC and not in the   list above.   We could (and did) take the view that all CCN users are concerned   only with writing and executing normal 360 programs using EBCDIC and   that they would enter one of the maverick ASCII graphics only in   error.  Our original choice, therefore, was to map the mavericks in   the input into EBCDIC question marks.  We also assumed that, if a   user needs to access a larger subset of EBCDIC than the basic 89, he   should do so by doing his rje directly in EBCDIC.   We now realize that there were two deficiencies in the original   mapping rules.      1. The 360 program may be intended to manipulate ASCII text from          the Network.  In that case, the Network user needs to have all          ASCII characters, including the mavericks, uniquely mapped          into EBCDIC in some (standard) manner.      2. The present mapping is convenient only if a user at an AT&T          Model 33/35 Teletype (or simulator thereof) needs a different          mapping for ease of use.   For the first case, we have changed the mapping of the 6 maverick   ASCII characters from "?", using instead Winett's rules III (c) and   III (d):      ASCII             EBCDIC      -----             ------        [                X'AD'        ]                X'BD'        {                X'8B'        }                X'9B'        ^                X'71'        `                X'79'   For the user with a Model 33/35 Teletype, we have expanded the set of   virtual remote batch terminal types, adding "TTY" to "ASCII" and   "EBCDIC".  A user establishes his virtual remote batch terminal as   type TTY by either doing his initial ICP to socket 15 (vs. 11 for   EBCDIC, 13 for ASCII), or by doing an ICP to Socket 1 and entering   the command "TTYRJS" (vs. "RJS" for EBCDIC, "ARJS" for ASCII).  The   mapping used by NETRJS for a TTY remote is:Braden                                                          [Page 3]RFC 338           EBCDIC/ASCII MAPPING FOR NETWORK RJE          May 1972   Model 33          Corresponding   Graphic               ASCII               EBCDIC   --------          -------------           ------      \                   \                   <bent bar>    <up arrow>            ^                     |    <left arrow>          _                     _      [                   [                  <cent sign>      ]                   ]                   X'BD'   This is ugly, but it is probably the best we can do.D. CONCLUSIONS   It is obvious that one pair of translation tables won't do the job;   NETRJS needs (at least) two mappings for each direction.  How long   will it be before an important set of users appears with a different   terminal character set, requiring yet a different mapping? [6] An rje   server site needs to be prepared to provide a variety of translation   tables, and perhaps to allow a user to specify his own table(s); this   mini-subset of "Date Reconfiguration Service" might be necessary to   prevent translation-table-proliferation.  The tendency in Network   discussions has been to put the burden upon the user sites to adapt   to different conventions.  In the real world of users and servers,   the server will often have to do the adapting.NOTES AND REFERENCES      [1] R.T. Braden, Interim NETRJS Specifications, RFC #189 (NIC          #7133), July 15, 1971.      [2] Please note that "RJS" is the proper name of a particular rje          package written at CCN the generic name for remote batch          service is "rje".      [3] Notice that the mapping question discussed in this RFC is          significant only for the virtual card reader and printer          connections in NETRJS.  The punch connection is always          transparent, i.e., never translated.  The remote operator          connections use the extended EBCDIC/ASCII mapping including          the maverick characters, but this is not important since          operator commands require only a limited character set.      [4] Joel Winett, "_The_ EBCDIC Codes and their Mapping to ASCII",          RFC #183 (NIC #7127), July 21, 1971.Braden                                                          [Page 4]RFC 338           EBCDIC/ASCII MAPPING FOR NETWORK RJE          May 1972      [5] Winett lists only 88 basic EBCDIC graphics, excluding the          space which he regards as a control character.  This is a          matter of taste, but we find it less confusing to include the          space as a graphic.      [6] CCN recently received a new Teletype-replacement terminal.          This machine has a bastardized graphic character set -- mostly          ASCII, with a sprinkling of both (!) EBCDIC and TTY.              +-------------------------------------+              |                          Full ASCII |              | a b ... z  | ` ^ { }  ~             |              |                                     |        +-----+-------------------------------------+--------------+        |33/35|                                     |   AT&T TWX   |        |     |          `   [   ]                  | (Mod 33/35   |        |     |                                     |      tty)    | +------+-----+------+-----------------------+      |              | |Basic |     |      |                       |      |              | |EBCDIC|     |      |     <SP>              |      |              | |      |     |   "  |     A B ... Z         |      | <left arrow> | |      |     |   !  |     0 1 ... 9         |      |              | |      |     |      |     + - * / ( )       |      |  <up arrow>  | |      |     |      |     . , ' =           |      |              | |      |     |      |     $ &               |      |              | |      |     |      |   < > : ? % # @       |      |              | |      |     |      |                       |      |              | |      +-----+------+-----------------------+------+--------------+ |            |      |                       |      | |            |      |        _              |      | |            |      |                       |      | |            +------+-----------------------+------+ |                   |                       | |                   | PL/1   <bent bar> |   | |                   |  Set                  | |                   +-----------------------+ |                           <cent sign>     | |  Basic EBCDIC                             | +-------------------------------------------+               Figure 1.  Character Sets Commonly Abused[This RFC is also available in .PS and .PDF format.]        [This RFC was put into machine readable form for entry]    [into the online RFC archives by Helene Morin, Viagenie, 12/99]Braden                                                          [Page 5]RFC 338           EBCDIC/ASCII MAPPING FOR NETWORK RJE          May 1972Braden                                                          [Page 6]